Foam Topper on a Foam Mattress: What Works and What Doesn't

Which topper and foam mattress combinations work, why memory foam on memory foam often backfires, and what to use instead.

Not Swiss Cheese Updated 4 min read

The short version

  • A topper on a foam mattress works when it fixes a specific problem; stacking two layers with the same weakness makes it worse.
  • Memory foam on a soft or hot memory foam mattress usually backfires: more heat, more sink.
  • A medium-firm latex topper firms up a soft foam mattress and sleeps cooler. See our latex mattress toppers.
  • Unsure whether your foam mattress needs a topper or replacing? Find out with our free mattress check.

You have a foam mattress, it is not quite right, and you are wondering whether a foam topper on top will fix it or just make things worse. The answer depends on what kind of foam is underneath, what kind you put on top, and what you are trying to fix.

Short version: it works well when the topper fixes a specific problem with the mattress. It goes wrong when you stack two layers that share the same weakness.

Which combinations work?

Your mattress Topper Result
Memory foam, too firm Memory foam topper Softer, more hugging. Can get warm.
Memory foam, too soft or dipping Memory foam topper Usually worse. Two slow, soft layers let your hips sink further.
Memory foam, too soft or dipping Medium-firm latex topper Firmer, more supportive, easier to move on.
Memory foam, sleeps hot Latex or wool topper Cooler. A breathable layer sits between you and the foam.
Memory foam, sleeps hot Memory foam topper Hotter. Avoid.
Basic polyurethane foam, too hard Plush latex or memory foam Softer, better pressure relief.
Hybrid (foam over springs), tired top layer Latex topper Revives the comfort layer that wore out first.

Memory foam topper on a memory foam mattress

This is the most common combination, and it only works in one situation: your memory foam mattress feels too firm and you want it to feel softer and more contouring. Two memory foam layers will feel very plush.

In almost every other case it backfires. Memory foam softens with heat and recovers slowly. Put two layers together and you double both: more heat, more sink, and a hollow you have to climb out of every time you turn over. If your mattress already feels too soft, too warm or has a dip, a second layer of memory foam will make it worse.

Latex topper on a foam mattress

A natural latex topper does the jobs memory foam struggles with. It pushes back evenly, so it firms up a mattress that has softened. It springs back the moment you move, so you are not fighting the bed when you turn. And its open-cell structure lets air through, so it stays cooler on top of a warm foam mattress.

Choose Supportive (medium-firm) to firm up a soft foam mattress, or Plush (medium-soft) to soften a hard one while keeping it supportive.

What problem are you fixing?

"My foam mattress is too soft"

Add support, not more foam. A medium-firm latex topper, 2 or 3 inches, is the best fix. See our firm mattress toppers.

"My foam mattress is too hard"

Add give. A plush latex topper or a memory foam topper both work. Latex will stay cooler and last longer. See our soft mattress toppers.

"My foam mattress is too hot"

Add a breathable layer. Latex or wool, never more memory foam.

"My foam mattress has a dip"

A topper can smooth a shallow dip. If you can see a deep one, the foam has broken down and the mattress needs replacing. Here is how often a mattress needs replacing, and how to tell.

How thick should the topper be?

  • 1 inch: fine-tunes the feel of a newer mattress.
  • 2 inch: the right choice for most foam mattresses.
  • 3 inch: for a foam mattress that has softened a lot, or heavier sleepers.

Tips for a foam-on-foam setup

  • Use a topper with straps or a grippy base. Foam on foam can slide.
  • Put a breathable mattress protector over both, not a plastic-backed one.
  • Check your fitted sheets are deep enough for the extra height.
  • Rotate both the mattress and topper head to foot every few months.

For more on memory foam mattresses specifically, read can you put a mattress topper on a memory foam mattress.

Our topper

The Organic Topper is GOLS certified organic Dunlop latex in a GOTS organic cotton cover, with corner straps and a grippy base so it stays put on a foam mattress. Plush or Supportive, 1 to 3 inches deep, every UK size from £149, with a 30-night trial.

Frequently asked questions

Can you put a foam topper on a foam mattress?

Yes. It works best when the topper fixes a specific problem, such as a latex topper adding support to a soft foam mattress. A memory foam topper on a soft memory foam mattress usually makes things worse.

Will a memory foam topper make my memory foam mattress hotter?

Usually, yes. Memory foam holds heat, and two layers hold more. Choose latex or wool if you sleep warm.

What topper is best for a memory foam mattress?

A natural latex topper, for most people. It adds support, recovers quickly and is cooler than another layer of foam.

What we make

We make the toppers this guide talks about. Organic latex, hand-finished in the UK, sold direct.

Written by

Not Swiss Cheese

Fact-checked against the sources listed and our GOLS/GOTS certificates.

Free mattress check · 3 minutes

Revive your mattress, or replace it?

Answer a few quick questions about your bed and how you sleep. We'll tell you straight whether a topper will fix it, whether it's time for a new mattress, or whether you need nothing at all.

  • No sign-up
  • Honest verdict, even when it isn't us
  • Your own plan

Written by our founder. Free, and we'll tell you if you don't need anything from us.

Your mattress reportExample
Revive

Revive it. A topper should fix this.

  • Support: flat, no dip
  • Comfort: too firm for side sleeping
  • Pain watch: hips most mornings